What if American Idol.....

[VTacoKitty]

What if after the tenth season of American idol they took all the people that were super famous on all the idol years (not only the winners-the people that were super famous like runner ups, and people in the top 5 or so like Chris Daughtry) and they were going to compete for the ultimate idol? David, of course, would have to be there. We would make him win! Haha! And each week they would have to sing each others songs haha! I think this time around we would make him win

An idea to send to Simon Cowell maybe....

[Anna Christina]

Haha! My mom and I always talk about that. That would be SO AWESOME!

[Deszra]

That would be soo cool!!!!!! I would defintiely watch it!!! But i think if they were so famous, then it wouldnt really matter if they won the "Ultimate Idol" or not. U know??

[Emily]

I wouldn't think David would win...but heck yeah that would be awesome!!!

Adam Lambert or Kelly Clarkson would probably end up winning...just saying. They seem like they have a furious/big fan base...and well Kelly, she was the ORIGINAL IDOL. The first champion.

In the end, I really agree with Deszra that it wouldn't matter who won, because they're all so popular already.

I know some people who probably would be in:
Jordin Sparks
Kelly Clarkson
Kris Allen
Chris Daughtry
David Archuleta
David Cook
Carrie Underwood
Adam Lambert
Allison Iraheta
Clay Aiken
Taylor Hicks
Elliott Yamin
...and of course many others but I'm not going to name them all...probably all winners, most runner-ups, and a few other people from like the top 10 or so.

[Char]

I actually thought of that a few times. Except I thought more along the lines of the top two from every season in a super competition. I would be so confused on who to vote for lol it's not fair. I really like Archie of course, that's an understatement but i also really dig Kelly Clarkson. Oooh!

[Anya lofamia]

well.. i definitely think archie would win.. no doubt about that.. and that would be so coollll!!!

[Jc..,]

well.., what i actually thought was that all the American Idols (winners) would compete for the title of ultimate American Idol.., hehehe.., they would sing a much more different songs and interpret it on each of their own versions.., since their all famous already they should really impress the people so to convince them to vote for them..,

[VTacoKitty]

Haha true...but it would be fun because then we can make David win just for the fun of it haha! XD

Deszra said:

That would be soo cool!!!!!! I would defintiely watch it!!! But i think if they were so famous, then it wouldnt really matter if they won the "Ultimate Idol" or not. U know??

[VTacoKitty]

Yeah. like Danny from last year would probably be one there....and Sanjaya (ICK) and myabe Kelly Pickler and those people that made successsful albums haha

Emily said:

I wouldn't think David would win...but heck yeah that would be awesome!!!

Adam Lambert or Kelly Clarkson would probably end up winning...just saying. They seem like they have a furious/big fan base...and well Kelly, she was the ORIGINAL IDOL. The first champion.

In the end, I really agree with Deszra that it wouldn't matter who won, because they're all so popular already.

I know some people who probably would be in:
Jordin Sparks
Kelly Clarkson
Kris Allen
Chris Daughtry
David Archuleta
David Cook
Carrie Underwood
Adam Lambert
Allison Iraheta
Clay Aiken
Taylor Hicks
Elliott Yamin
...and of course many others but I'm not going to name them all...probably all winners, most runner-ups, and a few other people from like the top 10 or so.

[Hannah]

That would be pretty cool! Kelly Clarkson, Carrie Underwood or Chris Daughtry would probably win though.

[Kaitlyn]

That would be soooo cool but there would be so many people I would vote for!

[SupaSparks]

Pretty good idea! I'm super excited and hoping that your idea will materialize. I think that David will have many rivals though. Jordin Sparks is also an awesome idol. There's Carrie Underwood. and we can't forget Clay Aiken. so it will be kinda difficult to pick a winner.