OMG! THat would be amazing! Well, I would either pick, you can, to be with you, or angels in the alleyway. Oh or somebody out there! Actually, he could sing any song to me and I would be satisfied!! :) Oh Archie! lol.
1) "I'll Be"- I saw a video of him singing the song (by Edwin McCain) at his school talent show... and i LOVE that song!! :) (even though it was released like... a decade ago or something... :P) Fave Lyric: "The strands in your eyes, they color them wonderful, stop me, and steal my breath" =D
2) "Heaven"- Ackk! Yet, again, ANOTHER beautiful ballad... Fave Lyric: ahhh when he grinds his voice at, "Baby you're all that i want.." makes me melt... 8D
3) "The Next Ten Minutes" (from my alltime favorite musical, the Last 5 Years) It's a wedding song.. but it's SOOOO pretty!! Fave Lyric:"Will you share you're life with me, for the next ten lifetimes, for million summers, till the world explodes??" ahhh... geez, i would die... :)
4) "I'm Yours" - omg. I don't know which one I'd be doing- singing along or laughing. :) {his rendition of I'm Yours always gets me like that!} Fave Lyric: "I tried to beat you but you're so hot that I melted" (oh geez! haha xxD)
5) "Vanilla Twilight" by Owl City (and David has said that he likes Owl City! Yaaay! =D). Great song!! :) Fave Lyric: "Oh darling I wish you were here..." ^^